Chargeflow Report Reveals AI Gap in Chargeback Management

Chargeflow Report Reveals AI Chargeback Management Gap Chargeflow Report Reveals AI Chargeback Management Gap

AI adoption is increasing chargeback win rates for merchants, but it has yet to significantly change how many disputes businesses choose to contest. A new Juniper Research report, commissioned in connection with Chargeflow, finds that merchants using AI achieve a median 38% win rate on disputed chargebacks, compared with 27.75% among non-users. However, both groups contest and win the same median share of eligible chargebacks. The findings point to a gap between using AI to improve individual dispute outcomes and applying automation to the broader decision-making process.

Chargeflow Report Highlights AI’s Chargeback Automation Gap

Merchants are investing in artificial intelligence to improve payment dispute management, but adoption alone may not be enough to deliver the financial gains businesses expect. While AI users report better chargeback win rates than merchants without AI, the share of eligible disputes they actually challenge remains unchanged.

That is a central finding in The State of Chargeback Management: How AI Is Reshaping Performance, a Juniper Research survey of 121 enterprise merchants in the United States and United Kingdom. The report examines AI adoption, dispute outcomes, operational challenges, and the financial pressures associated with chargebacks.

According to the findings, merchants using AI achieve a median win rate of 38% among the chargebacks they dispute. Merchants that do not use AI report a median win rate of 27.75%, a difference of 10.25 percentage points.

However, both groups dispute the same median share of their eligible chargebacks: 6.65%. They also win the same median share of eligible chargebacks.

The distinction highlights an important limitation in current chargeback automation. AI appears to help merchants build stronger cases or improve the outcomes of disputes they already choose to pursue, but it has not necessarily changed the initial decision about which transactions are worth contesting.

AI Adoption Has Outpaced Process Automation

The report found that 80% of surveyed merchants use AI in chargeback management. Yet only 11% said their processes were mostly or fully automated.

This gap suggests that many businesses are adding AI capabilities to existing manual workflows rather than redesigning the entire dispute-management process.

Chargeback operations typically involve identifying disputed transactions, reviewing evidence, gathering order and delivery information, determining whether a dispute should be challenged, and preparing responses for payment providers.

AI can help organize evidence and support dispute submissions. However, if employees still make most decisions about which eligible chargebacks to contest, the technology may improve individual cases without increasing the overall volume of disputes merchants pursue.

Dan Moshkovich, Chargeflow’s VP of Go-to-Market, said merchants have largely introduced AI into manual processes. He argued that the next stage involves using AI to identify which disputes are worth challenging and building evidence for each case.

That shift would move AI from assisting with dispute preparation toward supporting decisions across the chargeback lifecycle.

Rising Chargebacks Increase Merchant Pressure

The findings arrive as merchants report growing exposure to payment disputes.

According to the survey, 65% of respondents experienced an increase in chargebacks over the previous 18 months. Among those merchants, nine in 10 reported growth of at least 10%.

The financial impact is also significant. Almost half of surveyed businesses estimated that chargebacks cost them between 0.5% and 1% of annual revenue.

Friendly fraud is another concern. The report found that 43% of respondents believe it accounts for more than a quarter of their chargebacks. Friendly fraud generally refers to legitimate purchases being disputed by customers, sometimes because of confusion, forgotten transactions, or intentional misuse of the chargeback process.

For merchants, distinguishing genuine fraud from customer-initiated disputes requires more than identifying suspicious payment activity. Businesses may need to examine transaction histories, order records, delivery confirmation, customer communications, and other evidence.

These demands make dispute prioritization an important area for AI applications.

Merchants Want Measurable Financial Returns

The report also examines what would convince businesses to invest more in AI-powered chargeback management.

A higher win rate was the leading requirement, selected by 39% of respondents. Another 34% prioritized recovering more revenue. Fewer than one in five identified time savings or lower operating costs as their primary justification.

Merchants also have high expectations for measurable improvement. Some 69% said an AI tool would need to increase win rates by at least 11 percentage points to justify investment.

For context, the difference between AI users and non-users in the survey was 10.25 percentage points. That is close to, but below, the improvement threshold identified by respondents.

Juniper Research concluded that AI has delivered incremental improvements but has not yet met enterprise expectations for performance gains.

Provider selection also appears to prioritize trust and data quality over price. The survey found that 72% of merchants consider data quality very important when choosing a provider, while 70% place the same importance on security and compliance. Total cost was rated very important by 31%.

This suggests merchants are evaluating chargeback AI as a financial and risk-management capability, rather than simply another operational software purchase.

Holiday Shopping Creates a Different Dispute Pattern

Seasonal commerce adds another layer of complexity. Some 77% of respondents said chargebacks increase during the December holiday period, although 58% expect lower chargeback losses during the 2026 holiday season than in 2025.

Chargeflow’s Data Lab, launched on October 22, analyzed approximately three million disputes across the previous three peak seasons.

Its analysis found that during the 2025 Black Friday to Cyber Monday weekend, 34.7% of chargebacks involved claims that orders had not arrived. That compared with 19.9% during a normal week.

Fraud-related claims moved in the opposite direction, falling to 27.2% from 37.8%. Chargeflow said similar patterns appeared across the 2023, 2024, and 2025 peak seasons.

The data indicates that seasonal dispute management may require different evidence and prioritization strategies. Delivery-related disputes become more prominent during major shopping periods, making shipment tracking, delivery confirmation, and customer communication particularly relevant.

From AI-Assisted Disputes to Intelligent Decision-Making

The findings point to a broader opportunity for AI in payment operations. Improving the quality of individual dispute submissions is valuable, but merchants may achieve greater operational impact if AI can also help determine which cases deserve attention.

That requires systems capable of evaluating evidence quality, estimating the likelihood of a successful dispute, identifying relevant transaction information, and supporting decisions about whether to proceed.

Security, data quality, and compliance will remain important considerations because chargeback systems handle sensitive transaction and customer information.

Juniper Research VP of Research Nick Maynard said the next phase of chargeback technology should focus on converting intelligence into measurable financial improvements, rather than automation alone.

For payment technology providers, the challenge is therefore shifting from demonstrating AI adoption to proving that their systems can improve recovery outcomes across the full dispute-management process.

Market Landscape

AI-powered chargeback management sits at the intersection of fintech, payment operations, fraud prevention, and revenue recovery.

The report highlights several developments shaping the market:

  • AI-assisted dispute preparation: AI can help merchants organize transaction records and supporting evidence for chargeback submissions.
  • Decision automation: The next opportunity is evaluating which eligible disputes are worth contesting, rather than simply improving submitted cases.
  • Revenue recovery: Merchants increasingly expect measurable improvements in recovered revenue and dispute win rates.
  • Friendly fraud management: Businesses need better ways to distinguish legitimate customer disputes from fraudulent claims.
  • Seasonal dispute intelligence: Holiday shopping changes the composition of chargebacks, increasing the importance of delivery-related evidence.
  • Data and compliance requirements: Merchants place substantial importance on provider data quality, security, and regulatory controls.

The competitive environment includes payment processors, fraud prevention platforms, dispute-management providers, and AI-powered financial operations software. Providers will increasingly need to demonstrate measurable business outcomes rather than relying on AI adoption claims alone.

Top Insights

  • AI-using merchants report a median 38% chargeback win rate, compared with 27.75% among businesses that do not use AI.
  • Both groups dispute the same median share of eligible chargebacks, indicating that AI adoption has not yet changed dispute-selection behavior.
  • Although 80% of surveyed merchants use AI, only 11% report mostly or fully automated chargeback management.
  • Data quality and security are major provider-selection factors, rated very important by 72% and 70% of respondents, respectively.
  • Holiday chargebacks increasingly involve delivery claims, which represented 34.7% of disputes during the 2025 Black Friday to Cyber Monday weekend.

Power Tomorrow’s Intelligence — Build It with TechEdgeAI

Grow Your
Brand Visibility

Looking to publish a press release, guest article, interview or podcast? Connect with us.

GET FEATURED
Subscribe

Sign up today for exclusive insights and updates.

Newsletter Signup